Where to Enjoy Boozy Milkshakes and Other Frozen Drinks for Grown-Ups Around New York City

by Jessica Klein on Jun 30, 2014 in Roundups

What’s better than a milkshake to both satisfy sweetness cravings and cool you down on a hot, summer day? Answer: a milkshake with added booze! New York City is full of these just-near-sickly concoctions, as bars around the city combine flavored vodka with ice cream and soft serve in ways unimaginable when it comes to at-home replications. On that note, here’s a piece of advice when it comes to boozy shakes: Don’t try to make them at home. Leave it to the experts (most of whom work in stylized burger joints) to get the ice cream to alcohol ratio just right, because it’s one of the most sensitive ones measured out behind the bar.

Birthday Party Shake ($9)
Momofuku Milk Bar (251 East 13th St.; 347-577-9504)
Almost horrifically sweet, this alcoholic milkshake adds Milk Bar’s birthday cake truffles to their signature cereal milk soft serve, bringing texture and rainbows (in the form of sprinkles) to this thick and creamy delight. The three ounces of spiced rum seems nearly inappropriate, here, but any incongruities manage to elude the palate and hit the brain just right.

Stumbles the Clown ($11.50)
Mel’s Burger Bar (2850 Broadway; 212-865-7100)
Included in this list largely due its amazing name, Stumbles the Clown also boasts a seriously unique aspect in its cotton candy flavored ice cream base. Added Stoli Vanilla makes this shake incredibly sweet, but if you’re going to get an alcoholic milkshake, sweetness should not present an obstacle.

Salted Caramel Pretzel ($11)
Sidewalk Cafe (94 Avenue A; 212-473-7373)
In the spirit of diving all in when it comes to alcoholic milkshakes, a concoction involving salted caramel vodka, graham cracker crumbs, and vanilla ice cream surely fits the bill. The salted rim (as well as the saltiness from the flavored vodka, sort of) helps offset the sweet in the way that makes chocolate-covered pretzels such a hit…but with alcohol, this time.

The All Nighter ($12)
Go Burger (1448 2nd Avenue; 212-988-9822)
Caffeine gets incorporated into this drink from all possible angles. Kahlua, Bailey’s, espresso, and coffee ice cream all make an appearance in this silky beverage. The smoothness of the ice cream and the Irish cream also remove any trace of grit one could have noticed from the espresso shot. All together, this drink would deserve its name, if it weren’t for the fact that alcohol and sweets counteract caffeine by making the consumer incredibly sleepy.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Bomb ($10.95)
Bill’s Bar & Burger Downtown (85 West St.; 212-894-3800)
Though the kiddie version simply includes toffee pieces, chocolate ice cream, and spiced peanuts, you can make it 21-plus by adding a shot of Jack Daniels Honey (which also adds four extra dollars to the price). This may seem like an unnecessary addition when the menu spells it out like this for you, but in reality, it tastes pretty good.

Triple Chocolate Disco Shake ($11)
Big Daddy’s (1596 2nd Ave.; 212-717-2020)
Everyone knows that chocolate and hazelnut represent the perfect flavor marriage. This boozy milkshake does not disappoint in terms of the combo, blending chocolate ice cream with Frangelico and crème de cacao for decadence that is only replicated in the establishment’s non-boozy milkshakes and insane pancake selection, which includes the likes of cookie dough and Oreos within the fluffy breakfast food.

Guinness Shake ($7)
Mark (33 St. Marks Place; 212-677-3132)
Guinness already has a thick, velvety feel to it. Turning it into a both palatable and alcoholic milkshake shouldn’t have been too hard. However, the trick to all of the rave reviews this drink garners amounts to somewhat of a misrepresentation regarding its name: There’s not actually any alcohol in it.

Photo: Mel's Burger Bar


Tags: Cocktails
Recent Articles
spacer

Feedback

How are we doing? Tell us what you like or don't like and how we can improve. We would love to hear your thoughts!

*Name:
*E-mail:
*Suggestions:
 
Behind the Bar: Liana Oster of Dante

Behind the Bar: Liana Oster of Dante

For this exciting installment of Behind the Bar, we had the incredible opportunity to sit down with Liana Oster, the head bartender at Dante in New Yo...read more ›

by The Drink Nation Jan 7, 2020
Pabst Blue Ribbon Launches Blue Ribbon Whiskey in Select US Markets

Pabst Blue Ribbon Launches Blue Ribbon Whiskey in Select US Markets

PBR has launched their own whiskey. Let's keep an open mind and see what is inside this bottle....read more ›

by Carrie Dow Sep 24, 2019
The Master Sommelier Scandal is Now the Subject of a New Investigative Series

The Master Sommelier Scandal is Now the Subject of a New Investigative Series

There's a new investigative series about one of the biggest scandals to ever hit the wine world....read more ›

by The Drink Nation Sep 13, 2019
SPONSORED
Drink Nation Store Rectangle
Using Peas to Make Gin Might Lead to More Environmentally Friendly Spirits, Studies Show

Using Peas to Make Gin Might Lead to More Environmentally Friendly Spirits, Studies Show

Scientists may have discovered a more environmentally friendly way to make one of the world's most popular spi...read more ›

by The Drink Nation Jul 23, 2019
Drink a Classic Cocktail for a Good Cause During Negroni Week, June 24-30

Drink a Classic Cocktail for a Good Cause During Negroni Week, June 24-30

Negroni Week 2019 is June 24-30, so drink this classic cocktail for a good cause....read more ›

by The Drink Nation Jun 19, 2019
What to Do if Your Uber, Lyft, or Cab Driver Ever Strays From Your Destination or Makes You Feel in Danger

What to Do if Your Uber, Lyft, or Cab Driver Ever Strays From Your Destination or Makes You Feel in Danger

If you're taking an Uber, Lyft, or cab and feel unsafe, there are steps you can take to protect yourself....read more ›

by Nina Starner Jun 19, 2019
Behind the Bar: Kat Corbo of The Study & Winner of Speed Rack 2019

Behind the Bar: Kat Corbo of The Study & Winner of Speed Rack 2019

This time on Behind the Bar, we spoke to Kat Corbo of The Study, who recently won Speed Rack 2019....read more ›

by The Drink Nation May 15, 2019
Boston Beer & Dogfish Head Have Merged in a $300 Million Deal

Boston Beer & Dogfish Head Have Merged in a $300 Million Deal

In a huge move for the American craft beer community, Boston Beer and Dogfish Head have agreed to a merger valued at $300 million dollars. ...read more ›

by The Drink Nation May 10, 2019
A New, High-End Blend of Jack Daniel's Whiskey is Now Available in the United States

A New, High-End Blend of Jack Daniel's Whiskey is Now Available in the United States

A new, high-end blend of Jack Daniel's whiskey, known as Jack Daniel's No. 27 Gold, which was previously only ...read more ›

by The Drink Nation Apr 15, 2019
Coopers' Craft Bourbon Is Now Available in 12 States With a New Barrel Reserve Expression

Coopers' Craft Bourbon Is Now Available in 12 States With a New Barrel Reserve Expression

Coopers' Craft Kentucky Straight Bourbon has debuted an entirely new label design, has expanded to more states...read more ›

by The Drink Nation Apr 3, 2019
SPONSORED
Drink Nation Home Bar Project Bottom Rectangle 2
View all Articles

Sign up to get weekly drinking news, bar reviews, events and more sent directly to your inbox!

Close